Current:Home > NewsWhen art you love was made by 'Monsters': A critic lays out the 'Fan's Dilemma' -SecurePath Capital
When art you love was made by 'Monsters': A critic lays out the 'Fan's Dilemma'
View
Date:2025-04-27 22:49:05
Last month, I gave a talk at a conference in honor of the late writer Norman Mailer. When I mentioned this conference in class to my Georgetown students, a couple of them blurted out, "But, he stabbed his wife." I could feel the mood in that classroom shifting: The students seemed puzzled, disappointed even. What was I doing speaking at a conference in honor of a man capable of such an act?
The situation was reversed at the conference itself: When I confessed in my talk that, much as I revere Mailer's nonfiction writing, I was just as glad never to have met him, some audience members were taken aback, offended on Mailer's behalf.
If Mailer's writing had always been as bad as his sporadic behavior there would be no problem. But as Claire Dederer points out in her superb new book, Monsters, the problem arises when great art is made by men who've done bad things: men like Picasso, Hemingway, Roman Polanski, Miles Davis, Woody Allen and, yes, Mailer.
Do we put blinders on and just focus on the work? Do geniuses, as Dederer asks, get a "hall pass" for their behavior? Or, do we "cancel" the art of men — and some women — who've done "monstrous" things?
I hope that Dederer herself doesn't turn out to be a monster because I flat-out admire her book and want to share it with my students. As a thinker, Dederer is smart, informed, nuanced and very funny. She started out as a film critic and credits Pauline Kael as a model for grounding her judgments in her own subjectivity, her own emotions.
The subtitle of Monsters is A Fan's Dilemma: the dilemma being still loving, say, the music of Wagner or Michael Jackson; still being caught up in movies like Chinatown or maybe even Manhattan. In short, Dederer wants to dive deep into the murk of being "unwilling to give up the work [of art you love], and [yet, also being] unwilling to look away from the stain [of the monster who created it]."
The #MeToo movement propels this exploration but so, too, does our own social media, biography-saturated moment: "When I was young," Dederer writes, "it was hard to find information about artists whose work I loved. Record albums and books appeared before us as if they had arrived after hurtling through space's black reaches, unmoored from all context."
These days, however, "[w]e turn on Seinfeld, and whether we want to or not, we think of Michael Richard's racist rant. ... Biography used to be something you sought out, yearned for, actively pursued. Now it falls on your head all day long."
Maybe you can hear in those quotes how alive Dederer's own critical language is. She also frequently flings open the door of the stuffy seminar room, so to speak, to take her readers along on field trips: There's a swank dinner in New York with an intimidating "man of letters" who, she says, likes to play the part, "ironically but not — ties and blazers and low-key misogyny and brown alcohol in a tumbler."
When she expresses distaste for Allen's Manhattan normalizing a middle-aged man in a relationship with a 17-year-old he tells her to "Get over it. You really need to judge it strictly on aesthetics." Dederer confesses to finding herself put off-balance in that conversation, doubting herself.
We also march through a Picasso show at the Vancouver Art Gallery in the company of Dederer and her children. At the time, she says they "possessed the fierce moral sense to be found in teenagers and maniacs, [and] were starting to look a bit nettled" at the exhibit's disclosures of Picasso's abusive treatment of the women in his life.
So where does all this walking and talking and thinking and reacting get us on the issues of monsters and their art? Still in the murk, perhaps, but maybe buoyed up a bit by a sharp question Dederer tosses out in the middle of her book:
What if criticism involves trusting our feelings — not just about the crime, which we deplore, but about the work we love.
To do that we'll have to think and feel with much greater urgency and, yet, more care than we are currently doing. As Dederer suggests — and Pauline Kael famously did — we should go ahead and lose it at the movies and then think hard about what we've lost.
veryGood! (8953)
Related
- Appeals court scraps Nasdaq boardroom diversity rules in latest DEI setback
- Who gets the first peek at the secrets of the universe?
- 'Resident Evil 4' Review: A bold remake that stands on its own merits
- Cryptocurrency turmoil affects crypto miners
- Mets have visions of grandeur, and a dynasty, with Juan Soto as major catalyst
- A Japanese company has fired a rocket carrying a lunar rover to the moon
- Every Bombshell Moment of Netflix's Waco: American Apocalypse
- Joran van der Sloot, suspect in disappearance of Natalee Holloway, to be extradited to U.S.
- Trump invites nearly all federal workers to quit now, get paid through September
- 'Forspoken' Review: A portal into a world without wonder or heart
Ranking
- Head of the Federal Aviation Administration to resign, allowing Trump to pick his successor
- Transcript: Rep. Lauren Underwood on Face the Nation, May 14, 2023
- Sephora 24-Hour Flash Sale: 50% Off Urban Decay, Dr. Brandt, Lancôme, and More
- Nordstrom Rack's Epic Clear the Rack Sale Is Here With $13 Dresses, $15 Jackets & More 80% Off Deals
- Tarte Shape Tape Concealer Sells Once Every 4 Seconds: Get 50% Off Before It's Gone
- A damaged file may have caused the outage in an FAA system, leading to travel chaos
- Shop the 10 Best Hydrating Body Butters for All Skin Types & Budgets
- Raiders' Foster Moreau Stepping Away From Football After Being Diagnosed With Hodgkin’s Lymphoma
Recommendation
House passes bill to add 66 new federal judgeships, but prospects murky after Biden veto threat
RuPaul's Drag Race Top 5 Give Shady Superlatives in Spill the T Mini-Challenge Sneak Peek
Proof Austin Butler and Kaia Gerber's Love Is Burning Hot During Mexico Getaway
Italy calls a crisis meeting after pasta prices jump 20%
Taylor Swift Eras Archive site launches on singer's 35th birthday. What is it?
Joran van der Sloot, suspect in disappearance of Natalee Holloway, to be extradited to U.S.
Beyoncé dances with giant robot arms on opening night of Renaissance World Tour
It’s National Chip & Dip Day! If You Had These Chips and Bowls, You Could Be Celebrating Already